Biodegradable vs. Compostable: Do We Really Know the Difference?
So far in this series we’ve looked at why “recyclable” doesn’t always mean recycled, how recycling works like a four-step relay where most of us only see the first leg, and what happens once your recyclables reach the Material Recovery Facility (MRF).
This time we’re stepping outside the relay to look at two words that appear on packaging constantly and get treated as the same thing: biodegradable and compostable. They aren’t. Mixing them up is one reason so much packaging ends up in the wrong bin.

Biodegradable is vaguer than it sounds
Almost everything biodegrades eventually. Banana peels do. Wooden chairs do. Even some conventional plastics do, just very slowly. So a label that says “biodegradable” and nothing else hasn’t told you how long it takes, what conditions it needs, or what’s left at the end.
Oxo-degradable plastics show where this goes wrong. They’re conventional plastics with additives that speed up fragmentation into very small pieces, as the European Commission described them in 2018. The EU then banned products made from them under the Single-Use Plastics Directive because of their contribution to microplastic pollution. The ban applied from July 2021.

Regulators are now going after vague claims more broadly. The CMA’s Green Claims Code sets out six principles for UK businesses, including that claims must be truthful, clear and not hide important information.
The February 2026 ASA rulings show how this plays out. On 4 February the ASA upheld complaints against Kit & Kin and The Cheeky Panda over baby products. On the wipes’ “biodegradable” claim, the evidence covered only one component, under controlled lab conditions, not the wipes as a whole. A bare “biodegradable” doesn’t hold up on its own.
“Compostable” has to be proven
A compostable claim needs testing behind it. In Europe the benchmark is EN 13432, which also applies in the UK as BS EN 13432. It tests whether packaging disintegrates under industrial composting conditions, biodegrades, and leaves compost free of harmful effects. A third-party certifier checks the results, so the claim doesn’t rest on the manufacturer’s word.
Home composting is a tougher environment, because a garden heap runs much cooler than an industrial facility. That’s what TÜV Austria’s OK compost HOME scheme is for. It requires at least 90% degradation within 12 months at ambient temperature, and one certified-product maker describes the test environment as around 20-30°C. Thicker items take longer.

Standards aren't global
Europe and the UK both work from EN 13432, tested by bodies like TÜV Austria. The US equivalent, ASTM D6400, sets similar disintegration and biodegradation requirements and is certified mainly through the Biodegradable Products Institute. The bigger gap isn't the paper standard, it's what happens after. Composting infrastructure in the US is far more uneven by state and city, and a January 2026 USDA ruling against adding compostable plastics like PLA and PHA to the approved organic-inputs list has created friction with California's own compostable-labeling law. A product can be certified compostable and still run into a state that won't recognize the claim.
Where compostable labels fall down
A compostable label only matters if the item ends up somewhere that can process it. In England, GOV.UK’s Simpler Recycling guidance says collectors don’t need to take plastic packaging labelled “compostable” or “biodegradable” in food waste collections. Industrially compostable packaging often ends up in general waste, where the certification makes little difference.
Home compostable items avoid some of that, but only if you actually have a compost heap. Plenty of people don’t.
Compostable always means biodegradable. Biodegradable doesn’t always mean compostable.

One example: Shellworks and VIVOMER
Shellworks, a UK company, makes VIVOMER, which it describes as a plastic-free biomaterial made by fermenting plant waste into a plastic-like material. The pellets run through existing plastic manufacturing equipment, which matters if you want brands to switch.
The idea is that it behaves like plastic in use, then breaks down in a home compost. Shellworks says it holds OK compost HOME certification, has food-contact approvals, and has been tested for microplastics, phthalates, BPA and PFAS. It says it has shipped over 8 million parts, though trade press reported 1.8 million in mid-2025, so the figure has presumably grown. These are all the company’s own claims, as we have no commercial relationship with Shellworks and haven’t seen the test reports. If you’re specifying it, ask for the certificates and check them against the certifier’s database.

What designers can use now
Compostable packaging isn't a single material anymore, it's a growing shelf of options, each suited to a different job. Mushroom Packaging, made by Ecovative, grows mycelium and hemp hurd into moulded protective parts that replace polystyrene foam and are home compostable in about 45 days. Green Cell Foam, made from US-grown cornstarch, does a similar job for shipping and cold-chain packaging, and can be composted or even dissolved in water. VIVOMER, the Shellworks material covered earlier, takes a different approach again, behaving like a conventional plastic through manufacturing and use before breaking down at home.
None of these replaces everything, but each works for a specific job: protective packaging, shipping insulation, food-contact items. Most didn’t exist ten years ago.
Before you specify any of them:
Ask for the certificate, not the brochure.
Check the certificate matches the claim. Industrial and home compostable are different certifications.
Check where your customers can actually dispose of it. A compostable pack bound for a bin that can’t process it has no environmental benefit.
The best time to ask these questions is at the start of the design process, before the default material is already chosen.



